A cento anni dalla Rivoluzione russa: 1917-2017
The “Second Russian Revolution”: Perestroika Between Reform and Disintegration
In this article, Federico Paolini interprets the Perestroika not simply as the collapse of the Soviet Union, but as a profound historical attempt to transform Soviet socialism from within. The text challenges the traditional Western interpretation that viewed the USSR as an immobile “totalitarian” system incapable of reform. Instead, it argues that the Soviet crisis of the 1980s emerged from a complex interaction between political stagnation, social change, economic decline, and the gradual erosion of ideological legitimacy.
At the center of the analysis stands Mikhail Gorbachev, presented not as the destroyer of the Soviet system, but as the architect of an ambitious and contradictory modernization project. According to the article, Gorbachev’s reforms represented a genuine ideological, political, and economic revolution built around three key concepts: glasnost (openness and freedom of information), uskorenie (economic acceleration), and perestroika (structural restructuring).
The essay insists that the Soviet Union was not a static monolith. Beneath the apparent rigidity of the Communist Party existed informal networks, reformist intellectual circles, and debates concerning the future of the Soviet economy and political system. Paolini therefore distances himself from the so-called “totalitarian school,” which interpreted Soviet society primarily through categories such as ideological monopoly, bureaucratic immobility, and absolute state control. Instead, he aligns partially with revisionist historians such as Moshe Lewin and Jerry F. Hough, who emphasized the importance of social transformations within Soviet society itself.
A major conceptual contribution of the article lies in its reinterpretation of Perestroika as a “second Russian revolution.” The reforms did not merely attempt administrative adjustments; they dismantled the essential pillars of Soviet authoritarianism. During Gorbachev’s leadership, the monopoly of the Communist Party was progressively weakened, censorship was relaxed, political pluralism emerged, and institutional reforms introduced competitive elections and a presidential system. The article stresses that these reforms created, for the first time in Soviet history, a fragile but authentic democratic public sphere.
Economically, however, the reforms produced contradictory results. Gorbachev attempted to liberalize parts of the Soviet economy without embracing full capitalism. The article highlights how this produced a hybrid economic system that combined the inefficiencies of state planning with the instability of market mechanisms. Inflation, shortages, declining productivity, and technological backwardness deepened the economic crisis and undermined public support for reform.
One of the most important dimensions of the essay concerns the relationship between political liberalization and nationalism. Paolini argues that the decisive factor behind the dissolution of the Soviet Union was not merely economic collapse or political conflict inside the Communist Party, but the resurgence of national identities across the Soviet republics. Glasnost unintentionally revived suppressed memories, religions, and nationalist aspirations that decades of Stalinist and Brezhnevian repression had failed to eliminate.
The article pays particular attention to the rise of Russian nationalism itself. Rather than presenting Russia as simply the victim of Soviet collapse, the essay argues that the emergence of a powerful Russian national consciousness played a central role in destroying the Union from within. In this context, Boris Yeltsin appears as a crucial figure. Paolini portrays Yeltsin as a political rival who exploited nationalist sentiment and institutional instability in order to weaken Gorbachev and strengthen the authority of the Russian Republic against the Soviet center.
This interpretation culminates in the analysis of the failed August 1991 coup. The attempted conservative reaction against Perestroika accelerated the collapse of Soviet institutions while simultaneously legitimizing Yeltsin as the defender of democracy. The dissolution of the Communist Party and the formation of the Commonwealth of Independent States marked the definitive end of the Soviet Union and the political defeat of Gorbachev’s federal reform project.
Yet the article refuses to reduce Gorbachev’s experience to failure. On the contrary, Paolini emphasizes Gorbachev’s historical achievement in transforming an authoritarian state into an open political system and in ending the Cold War without large-scale violence. The essay therefore distinguishes between political defeat and historical significance. Gorbachev lost power, but he permanently transformed both Soviet society and international relations.
The second major section of the article develops this argument further by examining Gorbachev’s foreign policy and his theory of the “new thinking for the world.” Here the essay moves beyond Soviet domestic politics and interprets Gorbachev as one of the last twentieth-century leaders to elaborate a global political vision based on cooperation, disarmament, social justice, and international interdependence.
According to Paolini, Gorbachev understood earlier than many Western leaders the growing importance of globalization, multinational corporations, technological inequality, and the emergence of new geopolitical centers beyond the bipolar Cold War order. The article highlights the originality of his reflections on global inequality, the Third World debt crisis, environmental issues, and the need for a new international economic order.
Central to this “new thinking” was the redefinition of peaceful coexistence. Unlike earlier Soviet doctrine, Gorbachev rejected the inevitability of military confrontation and promoted diplomacy, nuclear disarmament, and multilateral cooperation. The article stresses his critique of deterrence theory and his proposal for a universal system of international security grounded in political dialogue rather than military competition.
The essay also underlines the ethical and humanistic dimensions of Gorbachev’s worldview. Questions such as environmental protection, human rights, cultural cooperation, poverty reduction, and global inequality became central components of Soviet foreign policy discourse during the Perestroika years. Paolini connects these ideas to broader European social democratic traditions associated with figures such as Willy Brandt and to concepts of global solidarity emerging in the late twentieth century.
The notion of a “common European home” receives particular attention. Gorbachev imagined Europe not as a continent divided by ideological blocs, but as a cooperative political and cultural space founded on shared institutions, legal principles, and mutual security. In this sense, the article presents Perestroika not only as a Soviet reform project, but also as an attempt to redesign the architecture of international relations after the Cold War.
In its conclusion, the article offers a broader reflection on the legacy of the 1990s. Paolini argues that many of Gorbachev’s concerns — uncontrolled globalization, the growing power of multinational corporations, regional conflicts, social inequality, and the weakness of international institutions — proved remarkably prophetic. The collapse of the Soviet Union did not produce the equitable and cooperative world order imagined by the “new thinking.” Instead, it accelerated the triumph of neoliberal globalization and intensified global asymmetries of power.
Ultimately, the article presents Perestroika as both a revolutionary and tragic historical process. It was revolutionary because it dismantled one of the twentieth century’s most rigid authoritarian systems and attempted to redefine global politics through cooperation and justice. It was tragic because the very openness created by reform unleashed forces — nationalism, economic instability, political fragmentation, and struggles for power — that destroyed the Soviet Union before the project could stabilize itself. In this interpretation, Gorbachev emerges not as the naïve gravedigger of socialism, but as the last major political leader of the twentieth century to attempt a systemic alternative to both Cold War confrontation and unregulated global capitalism.
Readers interested in the history of the Soviet collapse, the transformation of socialism, and the global implications of the end of the Cold War can explore the full essay by Federico Paolini, originally published in Italian in Ricerche Storiche in 2000.
Commenti recenti