Southern Italy as Part of the Global South: History, Memory, and Public Narrative in the Songs of Eugenio Bennato

At first glance, framing Southern Italy within the interpretive category of the Global South may appear geographically imprecise. Yet, from a historical, symbolic, and cultural perspective, this lens proves remarkably productive—especially when examined through the musical work of Eugenio Bennato. His songs, as clearly illustrated in the analyzed material , articulate a public discourse that intertwines historical memory, subaltern identity, and resistance. In doing so, they reposition Southern Italy within a broader constellation of “southern” experiences across the world.

The South as a Historical and Political Construction

In Bennato’s repertoire, the South is never merely a geographical entity; it is a historical construct shaped by asymmetric power relations. Songs such as Brigante se more and Ninco Nanco revisit the phenomenon of post-unification brigandage, challenging the dominant narrative that reduces it to mere criminality.

Instead, the brigand emerges as a political figure—a symbol of resistance against what can be interpreted as a form of internal colonization. The lyrics explicitly stage a conflict between local populations and the Piedmontese state, framing it as both a military and epistemic struggle:

“O ver’ lup’ ca magn’ e creatur’ / È o piemuntese c’avimm’ ‘a caccià”

This reinterpretation aligns closely with postcolonial perspectives, in which Southern Italy is portrayed as a marginalized periphery subjected to domination, silencing, and historical misrepresentation.

Erased Memory and Economic Subalternity

Another key axis in Bennato’s work is the theme of historical erasure. The song Mongiana narrates the rise and fall of a major Calabrian steel industry, dismantled shortly after Italian unification. The factory becomes a powerful symbol of a forgotten industrial South, excluded from the national narrative.

The repeated question—“What happened to…?” —is not merely rhetorical. It points to a deeper epistemological issue: what is not remembered, recorded, or narrated is effectively rendered nonexistent.

This dynamic mirrors broader patterns typical of the Global South:

  • the loss of economic centrality
  • the rewriting or suppression of historical memory
  • the production of reductive stereotypes (backwardness, poverty, deviance)

Popular Culture as a Form of Resistance

Bennato assigns an explicitly political function to music. In Balla la nuova Italia, popular culture becomes a site of dissent:

“La canzone del dissenso / Contro i giochi del potere”

Here, music is not passive folklore but an active practice of resistance and identity formation. The use of traditional rhythms and forms—such as the tammurriata—is not nostalgic, but strategic. Reclaiming cultural heritage becomes a way to oppose homogenization and assert symbolic autonomy.

This dimension resonates strongly with subaltern cultures worldwide, where music and oral traditions often serve as crucial tools for preserving memory and articulating political critique.

The South as a Universal Category

In Addio Sud, Bennato takes a further conceptual step: the South is no longer just a localized condition but becomes a universal category, almost existential in nature.

“Perché il sud non è un errore / Ma è soltanto un sentimento”

The South is thus redefined as:

  • a symbolic space of exclusion
  • a horizon of possibility
  • a dynamic and evolving identity

References to “colonial pasts” and “overseas lands” explicitly broaden the framework, connecting Southern Italy to global histories of domination and resistance.

Southern Italy and the Global South: Toward a Convergent Interpretation

From this perspective, it becomes possible to interpret Southern Italy—at least in Bennato’s narrative universe—as part of a broader Global South, not in strictly geographical terms, but as a shared condition shaped by analogous historical processes.

Bennato’s songs implicitly construct a bridge between the Mezzogiorno and other marginalized regions of the world, revealing striking parallels. The political dynamics of post-unification Southern Italy, for instance, can be read through the lens of internal colonization, echoing the external colonial experiences that have defined much of the Global South. Similarly, the economic marginalization and deindustrialization described in Mongiana resonate with patterns of dependency and uneven development observed in postcolonial economies.

On a cultural level, the persistent stereotyping of Southern Italy—reduced to images of backwardness, folklore, or deviance—mirrors the processes of exoticization and simplification often imposed on non-Western societies. Against this backdrop, Bennato’s emphasis on music as a vehicle of resistance aligns with a broader global tradition in which subaltern communities use cultural production to reclaim agency, preserve memory, and challenge dominant narratives.

What emerges, therefore, is not a simplistic equivalence between Southern Italy and the Global South, but rather a convergence of structural and symbolic conditions. In Bennato’s work, the South becomes a relational category: a way of understanding how power operates across different contexts, producing similar forms of exclusion, resistance, and cultural creativity.

Conclusion

Eugenio Bennato’s songs function as powerful instruments of counter-narration. Through music, Southern Italy is reimagined as a space of conflict, memory, and resistance—one that enters into a meaningful dialogue with the experiences of the Global South.

In this sense, his work does more than recover forgotten histories. It contributes to a critical re-mapping of the contemporary world, where the Mezzogiorno is no longer seen as a passive periphery, but as an active site of cultural and political production, capable of generating new meanings and alternative futures.

Federico Paolini

This article is part of the research project: Music, Power and Global Inequality

Potrebbero interessarti anche...